Supreme Court Sidesteps Maryland ‘Sensitive Places’ Gun Case

The justices turned away the Second Amendment challenge without comment, leaving a Richmond appeals court ruling for Maryland in place.

KEY POINTS

  • The Supreme Court on Monday turned away a challenge to Maryland’s “sensitive places” gun bans, leaving the restrictions in force.
  • Justice Clarence Thomas said he doubts the bans are lawful but agreed this sweeping challenge was the wrong case to take.
  • On Dec. 2, the justices will hear a separate challenge to state bans on assault-style rifles.

WASHINGTON — Maryland is allowed to prohibit firearms at sports venues, bars, hospitals and many other public places. The Supreme Court ensured that on Monday, by declining to rule on the matter.

In turning away an appeal of Maryland’s “sensitive places” law, the justices offered no comment of their own, according to USA TODAY. In effect, they preserved a Richmond-based appeals court decision that upheld the law. Decisions elsewhere have arrived at similar conclusions, although the logic may vary, as does the list of places included.

Gov. Wes Moore signed Maryland’s law in 2023. It extends to college campuses, hospitals, power plants and amusement parks, Reuters reported, and includes businesses that sell alcohol or cannabis for use on the premises. Earlier Maryland rules had already banned guns on public transit, in casinos, schools and at public protest sites.

Thomas doubts the bans, but not this case

Justice Clarence Thomas has openly declared his skepticism that the Second Amendment allows Maryland to ban guns in so many places. Yet Thomas joined in turning the case away, because the challenge swept too broadly — a breadth that, in his words, “would complicate our review.”

“In an appropriate and more narrowly focused case, however, we should consider the scope of States’ authority to ban firearms in ‘sensitive places,’”

— Justice Clarence Thomas

For the gun owners and advocacy groups who brought the case, the result means the muddle continues. They have called the lower courts’ decisions “an incoherent morass” and asked the justices to sort it out.

Adam Kraut, executive director of the Second Amendment Foundation, said the court “has been clear that the Second Amendment protects a right for individuals to carry for self-defense as they go about their daily lives.” He added: “Put bluntly, when forced by the Supreme Court to issue carry permits, Maryland simply made those permits useless everywhere.”

Maryland said the challengers’ definition of a sensitive place was too restrictive. It would allow bans only in facilities protected by armed government security, such as a federal courthouse.

The Bruen test, and what comes next

All of this runs through New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen, decided in 2022. The 6-3 decision said gun regulations must be “consistent with this nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation.” It was the first time the court had said the Second Amendment protects an individual’s right to carry a handgun in public for self-defense.

What Bruen failed to do was define “sensitive places,” although it used the term. After 2022, Democrat-led states filled the gap with their own lists. Maryland’s list has survived Monday’s order intact.

On Dec. 2, the court will hear a challenge to the legality of state restrictions on assault-style rifles, Reuters reported, in a case involving a type of weapon often associated with mass shootings.

Comments
Advertisements
▶ Watch: Mountain Tang — Taste the Freshness
Follow Virginia Times on Facebook for news as it happensFollow
- Advertisement -
VT Newsroom
VT Newsroom
VT Newsroom is the editorial team of Virginia Times, published by Global News Break LLC. We cover Virginia, Washington and the world — politics, public policy, business, sports, entertainment and community news — reporting from primary sources and official statements whenever possible.

Latest news

Related news

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here