Justice Department Asks Supreme Court to Halt Venezuela TPS Ruling

The government says reviving the protections after 19 months could force the release of about 1,800 detained Venezuelans

Key Points

  • The Justice Department asked the Supreme Court to halt a ruling reviving Venezuela TPS, seeking an immediate administrative stay before Nov. 20.
  • The government says revival after 19 months could force the release of about 1,800 detained Venezuelans and block up to 332 removal orders.
  • The filing relies on the June Mullin v. Doe ruling and asks the justices to freeze the district court’s judgment during the appeal.

WASHINGTON — The Justice Department asked the Supreme Court on Wednesday to stop a federal judge’s ruling from reviving temporary protected status for Venezuelans on Friday. It is the government’s third request for a stay from the justices in the case.

Solicitor General D. John Sauer filed the emergency application on behalf of Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin. It asks the court for an immediate administrative stay while the justices consider a longer pause.

Without one, a September 2025 order from the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California takes effect Nov. 20, when a Ninth Circuit administrative stay runs out. That order set aside the end of Venezuela’s 2023 TPS designation.

The filing says the Department of Homeland Security would then have to restore TPS for hundreds of thousands of Venezuelans after a 19-month gap. During that time, according to the government, the department ended work permits, placed people in removal proceedings, secured removal orders and detained thousands.

Government lawyers wrote that they had been told about 1,800 detained Venezuelans could have to be released right away. Up to 332 final removal orders could not be carried out, and the government would have to issue work permits to an unknown number of people, the application says.

Federal law bars the removal of TPS holders and bars detaining them based on immigration status alone. Because of that, the filing argues, people released could not be put on ankle monitors and would have “an overwhelming incentive to flee” before the justices act on the request.

Government Leans on June Ruling

The government’s main legal argument rests on Mullin v. Doe, a June 25 decision on the Haiti and Syria designations. There, the justices read the TPS statute as shutting courts out of “all non-constitutional claims” against ending a country’s designation.

The Venezuela challengers sued under the Administrative Procedure Act. The district court ruled that then-Secretary Noem’s termination was arbitrary and capricious because she did not meaningfully consult other agencies or meaningfully review conditions in Venezuela. The application argues that Doe rejected the same kinds of claims.

The challengers themselves acknowledged in an Oct. 15 brief that their statutory challenges to the termination didn’t survive Doe, the filing says. What they still press is a separate claim against Noem’s earlier move to cancel an 18-month extension approved under the prior administration.

In the government’s view, the termination made that cancellation beside the point. And even if the cancellation was flawed, its lawyers argue, the termination still kicked in once the extension ran out at the end of Oct. 2.

In the lower court, the Venezuelans pointed to the danger of being sent back home. They also cited family separation, deportation to third countries and lost work permits, the application says.

The government’s answer is that the justices have heard those arguments twice and sided with it both times. This account comes from the government’s filing, which doesn’t include a response from the National TPS Alliance or the individual plaintiffs.

Filing Faults Ninth Circuit

The Supreme Court vacated the Ninth Circuit’s ruling in the case on Oct. 5 and sent it back for another look in light of Doe. That same day, government lawyers went to the appeals court seeking a stay and asked for a ruling by Oct. 26.

On Oct. 30, the Ninth Circuit turned down the request in a single unexplained paragraph, the filing says. It also refused the government’s backup request for a 21-day administrative stay.

Four days later, the court withdrew that order without explanation. In its place came a 14-day administrative stay beginning Nov. 6. The court also gave both sides until Nov. 10 to brief what Doe means for the case.

The government didn’t wait for the deadline. It filed on Nov. 6 and pressed for a decision by Nov. 13. The appeals court has not acted on that request, according to the application.

Sauer called the Ninth Circuit’s refusal “inexplicable.” The justices, he wrote, should reject the appeals court’s “gamesmanship.”

Third Visit to the High Court

Then-Secretary Mayorkas first designated Venezuela for TPS in March 2021 and redesignated the country in October 2023. On Jan. 17, 2025, he extended the 2023 designation for 18 months.

Noem then canceled that extension. She ended the 2023 designation as well, in a decision announced Feb. 1, 2025, that took effect that April 7.

Her reasons included the national interest and public safety. She also pointed to strained city shelters, police stations and aid services, and to a possible “magnet effect” that could draw more Venezuelans.

The district court put the termination on hold in March 2025. The Supreme Court stayed that order on May 19, 2025, with one justice dissenting. After the judge granted summary judgment to the challengers on Sept. 5, 2025, the justices stayed that ruling too, on Oct. 3, 2025.

The Supreme Court’s most recent stay expired Nov. 6 under court rules. In the new application, No. 26A714, the government wants the district court’s judgment frozen until the Ninth Circuit appeal and any further Supreme Court review are done.

Comments
Advertisements
▶ Watch: Mountain Tang — Taste the Freshness
Follow Virginia Times on Facebook for news as it happensFollow
- Advertisement -
VT Newsroom
VT Newsroomhttps://virginiatimesnow.com
The VT Newsroom is the editorial desk of Virginia Times, an independent digital news outlet based in Burke, Virginia, operated by Global News Break LLC. The newsroom covers Virginia and the Washington, DC region — state and local government, courts, schools, business and community news — alongside national and world reporting. Editor and publisher: Sunil Dahal. News tips and corrections: [email protected]

Latest news

Related news

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here