COP31 Climate Talks Collapse Without a Deal as EU and Others Reject Final Draft

The Antalya Pact was not adopted on Sunday, two days after the summit was due to end, after the EU and other nations rejected a draft that never mentioned fossil fuels

Key Points

  • The Antalya Pact was not adopted Sunday, two days after COP31 was scheduled to end, after the EU and other nations rejected it
  • The 12-page draft never mentioned fossil fuels, the omission Ireland’s minister called unconscionable on the EU’s behalf
  • COP31 President Murat Kurum said there would be no new text; the last COP to end with no adopted deal was Copenhagen in 2009

ANTALYA, Turkey — UN climate talks collapsed on Sunday without a political agreement, after the European Union and other nations rejected the final draft deal and COP31 President Murat Kurum told the closing plenary there was no consensus to adopt it, Reuters reported.

“It is clear that there are parties in this hall who oppose this text. We recognise that there is no consensus on this document. Therefore, these decisions have not been adopted,” Kurum said, according to Reuters.

The failure came after more than two weeks of negotiations that had been due to end on Friday but spilled two days into overtime. Kurum, Turkey’s environment minister, said he could see there was no agreement, confirmed he would not advance any new text, and later left the stage while country representatives were still delivering speeches.

“There is nothing to do, we did all that we could. Since there are 196 countries, they will make the decision and we will respect their decision,” he said. In a later statement carried by Reuters, he added: “There will be no new text from now on. We will not be carrying out work on a new text in an environment where there is no consensus.”

A pact that never named fossil fuels

The rejected text, the Antalya Pact published by the UNFCCC on Sunday as a 12-page draft of 98 paragraphs, set out proposed measures to accelerate climate action. It would have conceded for the first time in a COP outcome that peak global warming is expected to breach 1.5°C, sought electricity at 35% of total final energy consumption globally by 2035, and set a joint goal for deploying carbon capture, utilization and storage at gigatonne scale by 2035.

In none of its 98 paragraphs did it name fossil fuels, or any move away from coal, oil and gas. All it did was recall the 2023 Dubai consensus in full — the agreement that first promised a transition away from fossil fuels.

That omission was the reason given for the rejection. Ireland’s environment minister Darragh O’Brien said the European Union could not support the proposed deal, in part because it made no mention of the fossil fuels that scientists say drive global warming, Reuters reported.

“It is unconscionable that we would have a climate act that makes no reference to fossil fuel, no reference to transitioning away from fossil fuels,”

— Darragh O’Brien, Ireland’s environment minister

Panama also said it could not support the text because it failed to address the scale and urgency of the climate crisis. Earlier on Sunday, Belgium’s climate minister Jean-Luc Crucke had called the text “unacceptable,” telling Reuters: “It’s not the end of multilateralism, but there has to be courage to say no.” Germany’s environment minister Carsten Schneider said a decision looked unlikely to pass now, noting many colleagues had already left, the conference having been meant to end two days earlier.


Pressure from oil producers

Observers at the venue said Saudi Arabia and other big oil-producing nations had pushed hard in negotiations for a text that left out explicit mention of fossil fuels while including carbon removal technologies, according to Reuters. The proposed deal also took the overshoot of the 1.5°C limit as expected, yet pushed for carbon-removal technologies to be developed more quickly so it could one day be reversed — wording critics said might serve as a licence to keep pumping oil.

A representative for the Saudi delegation told the summit he was surprised at the resistance to technology. “If indeed the climate challenge, as some have mentioned today, is so important, it makes no sense that solutions, concrete solutions… will be taken off the table,” he said.

Kurum had presented the package hours earlier as a consensus text. “While no one obtained everything they might have desired, everyone can find a place for themselves within this text — that is the very essence of consensus,” he said, in remarks carried by Reuters. “I hope that the decision emerging from this hall will demonstrate to the world that multilateralism is still capable of yielding results.”


First collapse since Copenhagen

The last time UN climate talks failed to get a deal adopted by all was in Copenhagen in 2009, Reuters reported. This year’s collapse came against the backdrop of competing crises, including wars and public outcry over the cost of living, and in a year when the UN’s environmental body confirmed in October that the rise in global temperature was set to exceed 1.5°C — the threshold countries agreed in Paris more than a decade ago to try not to exceed. The United States, the world’s largest historical emitter, was absent from the talks for a second year after President Donald Trump ended U.S. cooperation on climate policy.

The failure does not erase what came before it. While a blow to efforts to ratchet up international action, the collapse in Antalya does not wipe out the obligations agreed at previous summits or remove the technical and legal frameworks governing multilateral action against climate change, Reuters noted. The next summit, COP32, is scheduled for Addis Ababa in November 2027 — where the finance road map the Antalya Pact would have launched was supposed to report.

Comments
Advertisements
▶ Watch: Mountain Tang — Taste the Freshness
Follow Virginia Times on Facebook for news as it happensFollow
- Advertisement -
VT Newsroom
VT Newsroomhttps://virginiatimesnow.com
The VT Newsroom is the editorial desk of Virginia Times, an independent digital news outlet based in Burke, Virginia, operated by Global News Break LLC. The newsroom covers Virginia and the Washington, DC region — state and local government, courts, schools, business and community news — alongside national and world reporting. Editor and publisher: Sunil Dahal. News tips and corrections: [email protected]

Latest news

Related news

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here