Judge extends Memorial Circle arch order through Dec. 3

The judge is weighing injunction requests from several groups challenging the project.

KEY POINTS

  • Judge Tanya Chutkan extended the restraining order blocking construction-related work on the 250-foot Memorial Circle arch through Dec. 3, or until she rules on the injunction requests.
  • Chutkan found nothing material had changed since Nov. 5 and said preserving the status quo lets the court weigh the motions without interruption.
  • The consolidated suits were brought by the District and Virginia and by three Vietnam veterans and a historian; nine Kennedy family members are seeking to intervene.

WASHINGTON — A federal judge on Wednesday kept construction of a 250-foot triumphal arch in Washington’s Memorial Circle on hold, extending by up to 14 days a temporary restraining order that was set to expire Thursday.

U.S. District Judge Tanya S. Chutkan’s order keeps the restraining order in place through Thursday, Dec. 3, or until she rules on pending requests for a preliminary injunction, whichever comes first. The order she issued Nov. 5 “remains in full force and effect,” she wrote.

The restraining order bars the defendants from any construction-related work at or near Memorial Circle, including excavation, demolition, land disturbance, utility installation and road closures.

Why the judge extended it

Chutkan found good cause “for the same reasons justifying the TRO in the first place.” Nothing material has changed since she ruled that the District of Columbia and Virginia were entitled to the order, she wrote.

Briefing on the injunction requests wrapped up Wednesday, a day before the original order would have lapsed. Chutkan noted that the motions raise separate questions for three sets of plaintiffs: the District and Virginia, a group of veterans and a historian, and members of the Kennedy family. More time, she wrote, lets the court weigh them without interruption, and preserving the status quo until she decides is appropriate.

The defendants have 24 hours to deliver the order to the subordinates, employees, contractors, subcontractors and agents working on construction or site work for the arch. They must tell each one that a court order prohibits the blocked activities.

Who is challenging the arch

The order covers two lawsuits the court has consolidated. Three Vietnam War veterans and an architectural historian filed the first, Lemmon v. Trump, on Feb. 19. President Donald Trump is the lead defendant in that case.

The District and Virginia sued the National Park Service and others on Oct. 31. Their suit brings claims under the Administrative Procedure Act, along with ultra vires and mandamus claims. The court merged the cases the same day.

Nine members of the Kennedy family asked to intervene on Nov. 10 and filed papers supporting the injunction requests on Nov. 13. The government answered both filings Wednesday, according to the order.

How the case got here

The Interior Department issued its final decision approving the arch on Nov. 5. That night, Chutkan granted the District and Virginia’s request for a restraining order.

Both the veterans’ group and the District and Virginia filed for preliminary injunctions on Nov. 10. The District and Virginia also asked the court to stay the agency’s action and filed an amended complaint. The government filed a combined opposition Nov. 16, and the plaintiffs replied Wednesday.

Chutkan has not yet ruled on the injunction requests. If she hasn’t decided them by Dec. 3, the extended order expires that day.

Comments
Advertisements
▶ Watch: Mountain Tang — Taste the Freshness
Follow Virginia Times on Facebook for news as it happensFollow
- Advertisement -
VT Newsroom
VT Newsroom
VT Newsroom is the editorial team of Virginia Times, published by Global News Break LLC. We cover Virginia, Washington and the world — politics, public policy, business, sports, entertainment and community news — reporting from primary sources and official statements whenever possible.

Latest news

Related news

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here